This blog is a forum for discussion of literature, rhetoric and composition for Ms. Parrish's AP Language and Composition class

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Fugue and Counterpoint in THiaLH

In her essay, "The Conventions of Counterpoint and Fugue," Janice Fuller uses The Heart is a Lonely Hunter as the basis for her argument that Carson McCullers' works retain a constant presence of the two.

Fugue is a collection of melodies in one specific piece, while counterpoint is a term used to describe how each melody balances off of the other and manages to repeat itself. We see how this correlates to THiaLH through the recurring jumps between each character as they interact with each other and embrace their feelings of loneliness and struggle to exist in their society. However, Fuller tries to emphasize the actual importance of music within the novel, denouncing those who only note the "frequent direct references" to music in the novel and how it only functions as a "minor symbol," by making note of how music relates to each and every one of the characters, and saying that these direct references to music abound, "...Willie's harmonica tunes, the music from Biff's mandolin, the mechanical music of the flying-jinny, and the 'singing moan' of Doctor Copeland's voice," as well as the classical music Mick "enjoys in the dark," (Fuller 1). In order to realize the importance of the music, we first have to look at music at a term of its own. Instead of seeing it as pleasant mixture of rhythms and melodies, it's important for us to see it as the efforts of the musicians who make it to make themselves heard to the world, and to make the world see what they think and feel.

My question is this: how do the characters of the THiaLH try to communicate with others in the novel, what exactly are they trying to say, and how do the personal struggles of each character relate to one another?

5 comments:

  1. Kaare, I think your question is a valid one... now my question for you: how do you propose to answer it?

    ReplyDelete
  2. You have me confused. Do you mean in my own essay, or in the actual blog?

    ReplyDelete
  3. In your essay. That's a tall order for a blog!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm not asking what your answer is but what means you will use to ascertain an answer to this (essentially unanswerable but worth exploring) question. Does that make sense?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I only wanted people to post an example of such and explain. That doesn't seem too bad.

    As for going about answering it, I just plan on analyzing the various repetitions I see within each character and connecting them all. After reading the article I've been keeping track of recurring themes within them all since my essay will be centered around that.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.